Locations: 2552 45th St., Highland; 921D Ridge Road, Munster
Phone: 219-924-6464 (Highland), 219-836-4202 (Munster)
Fans of irresistible, delectable desserts know that Butterfingers Bakery, with locations in Highland and Munster, will more than satisfy any sweet tooth. Offering decorative, creative cupcakes, brownies, chocolate-dipped strawberries, cakes, cookies and more, it’s the go-to place to get your sugar fix and has been since 1985.
Owner Robert Haynes believes the quality of the products is what sets Butterfingers Bakery apart from the rest. “We have a great product and loyal customers that have been coming in since the day we opened,” says Haynes.
Cakes go far beyond the basic yellow and chocolate. Sour cream fudge cake, amaretto pound cake, apple Bavarian cake, cherry white chocolate mousse cake and hazelnut buttercream cake are just a few of the novel offerings.
Butterfingers is also a delicatessen, serving entrées, sandwiches and salads, and can make up sandwich trays, dessert trays and bag lunches to their customers’ orders.
Location: 8314 Calumet Ave., Munster
Location: 56 W. Lincolnway, Valparaiso