A comedian once observed the reasoning behind the term “horse sense” is that horses don’t bet on people.
With the Senate passage of SB 91, which is moving through the House, many may think Indiana's withdrawal from the federal Common Core education program is a sure bet.
After all, Common Core has become so controversial across the nation that Gov. Mike Pence said in his State of the State address, "When it comes to setting standards for schools, I can assure you, Indiana's will be uncommonly high. They will be written by Hoosiers, for Hoosiers, and will be among the best in the nation."
Senate Bill 91 voids Indiana’s education standards that were modeled after the Common Core and requires the State Board of Education to adopt new ones. This was welcome news to opponents of Common Core who were worried about lower academic standards, political indoctrination of students, state sovereignty and a move away from Indiana’s past standards that had received wide acclaim from various educational groups.
Some opponents of Common Core are beginning to wonder if some politicians and the education establishment are simply moving the shells around the table. They worry SB 91 could become a way to confuse parents with “new” standards that are actually Common Core by another name.
Notice what Chamber of Commerce lobbyist Derek Redelman, one of the Common Core’s leading advocates wrote: “It is unfortunate that SB 91 is being misreported in this way. In reality, it does not dump Common Core but allows the State Board of Education to continue the review of our state standards that is already underway. Per legislation that passed last year, that review will result in a set of recommended standards that could be identical to Common Core, an Indiana version of Common Core, or something completely different ... So in other words, SB 91 changes nothing.”
What does Redelman know that supporters of SB 91 do not? Hoosiers Against Common Core believes they have the answer. They have done an extensive review of the backgrounds of the individuals selected to sit on the state board’s evaluation panel and the College and Career Readiness panel that will create and evaluate the new standards.
Hoosiers Against Common Core found “an unhealthy pro-Common Core bias on these panels.” This is based upon the large number of members who have signed pledges of support for Common Core, testified in favor of it, or have been employed by education and testing companies pushing the national Common Core program.
At least half of one committee’s members, and one-third of the other charged with creating our own standards, have supported the controversial Common Core federal program.
Legislators who supported SB 91 and want Indiana to control our education destiny need to ask if the state board has set up a losing bet for parents who have concerns about our following the national Common Core standards.