SEOUL — Donald Trump doesn’t get it. He warns South Korea about “appeasement,” but who’s appeasing whom?

Yes, President Moon Jae-in, hero of the candlelight protests that lofted him as the liberal darling into the presidency after the ouster of the conservative Park Geun-hye, would love to go down in history as the one who brought about reconciliation on this conflicted peninsula.

No, that’s not going to happen any time soon, much to the chagrin of some of the ideologues and idealists counting on him to say yes to just about anything North Korea wants.

Confounding many of his more left-leaning followers, Moon is talking as tough as the conservatives who ruled for nearly 10 years until Park’s downfall. He’s chatting with the hated Japanese, and he’s vowing no more advances in North Korean technology for fixing a missile capable of delivering a warhead to the United States.

He’s also calling for strengthening the South Korean armed forces.

What do a legion of progressives have to say about their hero now?

With 72 percent of South Korean voters still enthusiastic about him, Moon advocates say he’s trying to have it both ways — talking tough to the north while hoping Kim Jong-un will calm down enough to make a deal with the south.

Trouble is, Trump, the ultimate wheeler-dealer, seems unwilling to make a deal that will satisfy the Moon government, much less the North Koreans.

Having spoken on the phone with Japan’s Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, Moon did get Trump on the line to agree, sure, South Korea should develop a missile that’s twice as powerful as the Hyunmoo in the south’s inventory.

But did they get around to the Korea-U.S. Free Trade Agreement, KORUS, that Trump would jettison along with all the other “unfair” deals of his predecessors?

Just as Moon is standing tough on North Korea, he’s not bowing to the United States on trade.

One good sign is that U.S. officials, keenly aware of Korean sensitivities, while not openly deriding Trump’s “appeasement” tweet, dissociate themselves with off-record comments like, “You know how he is … he doesn’t always mean what he says … don’t take him literally.”

Beneath the level of the White House and the Blue House, South Korean diplomats and officials at the unification ministry, responsible for carrying out policy with the north, are busy coordinating in Washington and other capitals from Tokyo to London. The goal is to line everyone up against North Korea.

Nobody seriously believes, of course, that Kim Jong-un might abandon his program for turning North Korea into a nuclear power. But what about that “red line” that Moon said North Korea must not cross? It’s far from clear exactly where that line is.

Such talk leaves one wild card, namely the Trumpster himself. On the streets of Seoul, no one quite trusts him not to take matters in his own hands and fire away.

Is Trump fully aware that North Korea might gain revenge by pouring conventional, old-fashioned artillery shells over the northern tier of South Korea, including Seoul and the industrial port city of Incheon?

What South Koreans want, though, is often about as unclear as what Trump will do.

Subcribe to the Times

Reporting like this is brought to you by a staff of experienced local journalists committed to telling the stories of your community.
Support from subscribers is vital to continue our mission.

Become a subscriber

Thank you for being a loyal subsciber

Your contribution makes our mission possible.


Donald Kirk has been a columnist for Korea Times, South China Morning Post many other newspaper and magazines. He wrote this for The opinions are the writer's.