Review: 'How Quickly She Disappears,' by Raymond Fleischmann

Review: 'How Quickly She Disappears,' by Raymond Fleischmann

"How Quickly She Disappears" by Raymond Fleischmann; Berkley (309 pages, $26).

"How Quickly She Disappears" by Raymond Fleischmann; Berkley (309 pages, $26). (Penguin Random House/TNS)

"How Quickly She Disappears" by Raymond Fleischmann; Berkley (309 pages, $26)


Something ominous happens in the opening pages of "How Quickly She Disappears" and it's not immediately clear whether it's the good kind of ominous.

Here's the sitch: An unhappily married woman senses her small-town life is about to be turned upside-down by the unexpected arrival of a handsome, older drifter whose looks are compared to a falcon. If every single detail in that sentence sends you into "Bridges of Madison County" Post-Terrible Writing Stress Disorder, I apologize, but don't shoot the messenger.

Fortunately, it's quickly apparent that Raymond Fleischmann, who wrote this tense, character-rich thriller, is a better writer than Robert James Waller and that "How Quickly She Disappears" is after something much different from what "Bridges" was. Instead of embarking on an affair with mysterious Alfred, Elisabeth enters into a "Silence of the Lambs"-style exchange with him after he kills a man and, from prison, makes unsettling overtures to her and her 12-year-old daughter, Margaret.

That's the good kind of ominous, and Fleischmann sustains it throughout "How Quickly She Disappears." We don't know exactly what Alfred wants from Elisabeth when he summons her to prison but we do know what she wants from him: Her twin disappeared when the sisters were adolescents and has not been heard from since. Alfred, it turns out, knows what happened but will only gradually reveal the details.

Smart, vulnerable and too quick to make life-alteringly bad decisions, Elisabeth is a fascinating character (the book is a natural for a movie adaptation, and Natalie Portman would be an excellent Elisabeth). We spend most of "How Quickly She Disappears" in her head, either as a child in the 1920s or a lonely adult in the 1940s. Fleischmann is particularly good at depicting the uncertainties of being both a parent and an outsider in an isolated town that closes ranks against newcomers. For extra isolation, this one's in Alaska.

Elisabeth uses a meditation technique, learned in childhood, to deal with all of her uncertainties. Her doubts deepen her character while Fleischmann's melodious prose gives us the lay of the land: "She heard the stiff, rhythmic beat of someone cutting wood. Then she heard the suck and sigh of her own breathing, the faint tick of Delma's claws as she traipsed through the living room. Listen. Someone laughed in the distance. Listen. A group of children hurried down the road, whooping as they played hoop and stick. Listen. Just listen. She closed her eyes. She tried to relax."

That lyrical passage is atypical of the propulsive "How Quickly She Disappears," which rarely pauses to reflect. But it's representative of how deeply we connect to the protagonist of Fleischmann's assured page-turner, in which every plot development hinges on grieving Elisabeth's yearning for a truth that has eluded her for almost all of her life.

Visit the Star Tribune (Minneapolis) at


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

LOS ANGELES - Jennifer Songster roved the crowded aisles of the small mom-and-pop shop, riffling through books in Khmer, the official language of Cambodia. Outside, the streets of Phnom Penh bustled. The air was thick and humid. Beads of sweat trickled down her face. She hadn't flown for 20 hours to marvel at Angkor Wat, the largest religious monument in the world, or stroll the white-sand ...

"The Committee" by Sterling Watson; Akashic Books (420 pages, $16.95) ___ At the University of Florida in 1953, it's not a standard duty for an English professor to have to deal with a dead body. But as Sterling Watson's compelling new novel "The Committee" opens, that's just what Tom Stall finds himself doing. After he hears a strange sound from his office in Anderson Hall, he runs out and ...

CHICAGO - This month, next month - and probably long into the future - if you pay any attention at all to the Chicago literary landscape, you're going to need to acquaint yourself with a handful of fresh names. No fewer than five debut novels by Chicago authors arrive on shelves this winter, an unusually strong showing. All are talented fiction writers and all have landed healthy deals with ...

"The Boston Massacre: A Family History" by: Serena Zabin; Houghton Mifflin Harcourt (296 pages, $30) ___ Serena Zabin's mention of "military men and women" in "The Boston Massacre: A Family History" is brief and in the middle of a sentence but it seems designed to bring readers up short: "Wait. Military women? In 1770?" Title notwithstanding, the Carleton College history professor's work isn't ...

I don't have a lot of regrets, but I have a few. I regret not learning a second language to the point where I can converse. I regret not learning to swim, and I regret giving up the violin. (Though my violin teacher might have thought that was the right decision.) And I regret not memorizing more poetry. But that is a regret I can do something about, right now. And I intend to. I've been ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News


Entertainment & Dining

Latest News

Local Sports

NWI Prep Sport News

Weather Alerts