Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Man charged with murdering teen during drug sale gone wrong

Man charged with murdering teen during drug sale gone wrong

Christopher A. Wells

Christopher A. Wells

Alizah A. Johnson

Alizah A. Johnson 

CROWN POINT — Charging documents unsealed this week allege a man shot a 15-year-old boy to death during a drug deal gone wrong March 11 in Hammond.

Christopher A. Wells, 18, of Hammond, claimed he shot Jesus Castillo in self-defense during a phone call with detectives March 12, hours after Castillo's body was found riddled with bullets in the back passenger seat of Wells' red Ford Explorer in the 6100 block of Marshall Avenue, according to Lake Criminal Court records. 

Wells has not yet entered a plea to one count of murder. He was extradited from Cook County and arrived at the Lake County Jail last week, online court records show.

The shooting occurred about 8 p.m. March 11 in the 2800 block of 164th Place in Hammond, where Castillo got into Wells' SUV to sell Wells marijuana and THC cartridges, court records state.

Castillo's friend told police Castillo appeared to be nervous when he arrived, and the friend watched Castillo package marijuana and THC cartridges in a plastic grocery bag ahead of his meeting with someone in a red Explorer, documents say. 

See a day in the life of Michigan City Police Officer Brian Wright in the latest Riding Shotgun with NWI Cops installment.

Witnesses said Castillo had been selling drugs, including marijuana, THC cartridges, THC wax, psychedelic mushrooms and LSD, according to court records.

Gunshots rang out seconds after Castillo got into the back seat of the red SUV, which sped off, the friend said. The friend called police and reported he heard shots and a car sped off with his friend inside. He then got a ride to another location, court records state.

Hammond police began looking for Wells after finding a paper temporary license plate registered to him while searching the crime scene on 164th Place, documents show.

Wells gave a conflicting statement about who was driving his car, initially saying he "kinda blacked out" after the shooting and parked the vehicle on a side street. He also told police he was in the front passenger seat and another man was driving.

The other man, Alizah A. Johnson, 22, of Hammond, told police he was driving Wells' vehicle, court records state. 

A Lake Criminal Court magistrate entered a not guilty plea March 31 on behalf of Johnson to one count of assisting a criminal, a level 5 felony. 

Wells and Johnson both told police Castillo got into the backseat of the Explorer, handed Wells a grocery bag and then said, "Give me everything." They claimed Wells pulled a handgun from his bag, pointed it at Castillo and told Castillo to get out of the car.

Wells told police Castillo briefly put his hands up, court records state.

"Then he reached down quick where he flashed a knife, or a gun, or something in his waistband," Wells told police, according to court records. "As he did that and like grabbed for it, he moved up toward me."

Johnson said Castillo lunged toward Wells after Wells ordered him out of the vehicle, records state. Johnson said he heard gunshots and drove off, record allege.

When disaster strikes, a weather safety toolkit could be the difference between life or death. For this reason, it's incredibly important to have one prepared before the next storm.

Wells told police he shot Castillo with a Taurus 9 mm gun, records show. He allegedly said he didn't know what happened to the gun and that he may have dropped it in the car, by the car or in a nearby field.

After Wells and Johnson parked the vehicle, they walked a distance and called an Uber to take them to a friend's house in Hammond, court records say.

Police recovered a firearm from Wells' vehicle after Castillo's body was found, but court records did not indicate its caliber. Crime scene investigators collected multiple spent 9 mm bullet casings from the front seats, driver's floor mat and rear seats, court records say.

Seven bullets were recovered from Castillo's body during an autopsy. He had 12 gunshot wounds, some of which were entry and exit wounds, according to court records.

Wells refused to speak to police in person, but asked a question at the end of his call with detectives.

"Do you know, by chance, did the other kid have like a — did he have a gun on him or was it a knife in his waistband or anything?" he allegedly asked.

Gallery: Recent arrests booked into Lake County Jail


Sign up for our Crime & Courts newsletter

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News


Entertainment & Dining

Latest News

Local Sports

NWI Prep Sport News

Weather Alerts