Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Comey defends decision in 2016 Clinton announcement at Sinai Forum in Michigan City

Comey defends decision in 2016 Clinton announcement at Sinai Forum in Michigan City

  • Updated

MICHIGAN CITY — Former FBI Director James Comey said he made the right decision when he announced just days before the 2016 election that Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton was under investigation over her use of a private email server.

After a summer of saying the investigation was closed, after finding nothing worth a prosecutor’s attention, the investigation team found more emails from her Blackberry among former U.S. Rep. Anthony Weiner’s account, Comey said.

He spoke before a sold-out crowd at the Purdue University Northwest Sinai Forum’s opening session at Blue Chip Casino’s convention center Sunday night.

Telling Congress about the reopened investigation could influence the election, but not telling Congress would be concealing information, which he refused to do, he said.

That could have rocked the nation and harmed the FBI’s reputation if the president faced criminal charges based on information that had been withheld, he said.

Comey said he decided to “float up, float forward and look back” while trying to decide what to do. That meant looking toward moral and ethical principles, including the basic values of truth and the rule of law, and deciding then what he would say about the situation in three years.

Political ramifications shouldn’t be considered, he decided.

“I’m sure there’s a diversity of opinions about the decisions I made, and that’s OK,” he said.

Comey, who was fired by President Donald Trump in May 2017, expressed his disappointment about what he sees as the GOP straying from the party’s basic values under Trump.

“I’m so concerned about the assault on values by President Trump, particularly truth,” Comey said.

“The things that attracted me to the Republican Party I don’t recognize in my former party anymore,” he said.

“I think the Democrats need to win” at least one house of Congress to provide a balance of power in the federal government, he said.

Trump shouldn’t be impeached, Comey said, because that would fuel divisions within the nation.

Integrity and truth, “that’s how we’re going to re-center ourselves,” he said.

“What do we have in common, exactly, as a nation? It’s values,” he said.

Comey acknowledged saying previously that Trump is not morally qualified to lead the nation.

“I describe President Trump as a forest fire,” he said.

“There’s going to be tremendous damage to the center of our country,” he said, but the nation will see new growth as a result.

From a historian’s point of view, the story of the nation is a line of progress. It’s a jagged line, with temporary setbacks like the rise of the KKK after World War I and the rise of McCarthyism during the Cold War, but each time that fever broke, he said.

“We’re always making progress, getting better,” Comey said.

Comey asked the audience to reflect on their attitudes.

“Think about what you thought about George W. Bush two years ago,” he said, drawing applause from the audience.

Then he urged the audience to think about their views about Barack Obama two years ago.

“These were people who were centered on the values of this country — imperfectly, but centered on it,” Comey said.

Negative comments by Trump and others about the Justice Department won’t do any damage in the long run, because no president is in office long enough to do that much damage, he said.

Justice Department personnel are feeling the effects.

“It’s hurting them now and sapping their spirit,” Comey said.

However, they also believe in the agency’s mission and core values, and that’s what drives them, he said.

“There’s not a deep state, there’s a deep culture, so it cares deeply about the rule of law,” Comey said.

After his speech, Pam Lignell, of St. Joseph, Michigan, said she changed her mind about him.

“I was upset with him. I was angry” after the 2016 presidential election, Lignell said.

“I’m really glad I came,” she said. “It changed my attitude.”

Lauren Winger, of South Bend, said she was glad to hear his latest speech on his tour promoting his book, “A Higher Loyalty: Truth, Lies and Leadership.”

“I’m glad he’s doing this. He needs to be heard,” she said.


Get Government & Politics updates in your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News


Entertainment & Dining

Latest News

Local Sports

NWI Prep Sport News

Weather Alerts