Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.

Dunes pavilion restoration plans could jeopardize grant money throughout state

  • Updated
  • 0

CHESTERTON — There could be far-reaching repercussions if plans for the restoration of the pavilion at the Indiana Dunes State Park don't meet federal criteria.

Emily Ferguson, Land and Water Conservation Fund compliance lead for the National Park Service, said Thursday that while negotiations are continuing between them and the Indiana Department of Natural Resources on compliance issues, a drastic result could be the withholding of federal grant money, not only for local state park projects but for other projects across Indiana.

The latest saga in the attempt to restore the pavilion came this month after activist groups alerted the NPS restoration plans had changed since that agency initially gave its approval.

The NPS review is necessary because the state park has utilized Land and Water Conservation Funds in the past and the property may not be converted to uses that do not support public outdoor recreation.

Chuck Williams, managing partner for Pavilion Partners LLC, said the plans at issue on the DNR's website are not the final plans for the project.

Jim Sweeney, co-founder of Dunes Action, said those new plans for the project were submitted to the DNR in February. However, those plans were never forwarded to the National Park Service to determine if the plans were in compliance with the federal Land and Water Conservation Fund.

Ferguson confirmed the NPS never received a new set of plans from the DNR for review.

Those new plans resulted in a letter from the NPS citing concerns.

"First, thank you for letting us know that the plans for the Pavilion Project had been updated. You were correct that we had not seen that new plans had been posted that were different from the version (dating to June 2016) that we previously reviewed," read a letter from Jeffrey P. Reinbold, assistant director in partnerships and civic engagement at the National Park Service.

The letter was addressed to Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility, who, along with Dunes Action, have been protesting plans to restore the pavilion and the contract awarded by the DNR to Pavilion Partners LLC in 2011 to renovate the deteriorating pavilion and operate food services at the state park.

Reinbold wrote in the letter the plans, posted on the DNR's website, "have changed enough" to require a new review "because the Pavilion Project no longer appears to be secondary and supportive of outdoor recreation."

He also called several changes "problematic." Reinbold said a letter was sent to the DNR on May 15, giving three options: revert to the original plan; submit updated plans for a new determination; consider a land conversion to add land to the park in compensation for the land lost to the pavilion.

The revised plans, Reinbold wrote, would result in the pavilion being much less open to the public than originally proposed and "that is the main basis for our current concern."

"The current plans turn the pavilion into a tavern on the lake," Sweeney said. "We've said all along that fine dining and rooftop pubs don't support the average beachgoers or campers."

Sweeney said the groups support "an appropriate" restoration of the building.

"We think we have a great partnership with the state," said Ferguson, adding there has been no deadline given to the DNR to choose one of the three options. "We think that would be inappropriate. We are all working together to reach the right resolution."

DNR communications director Tara Wolf did not answer specific questions on the issue or on what the DNR's response will be to the NPS.

"DNR has been working and will continue to work with the National Parks Service and Pavilion Partners to move forward," she said in an initial response. "We will update the website when new things are received," following a second request for information.

"No plans have been finalized," Williams said, adding the plans on the DNR website were used for space planning. Final plans for the restoration project should be completed in the next couple of weeks, he said.

Williams said the final plans will be consistent with plans that were reviewed by the NPS in 2017 and determined to meet Land and Water Conservation Fund compliance.

Williams said it is up to the DNR to determine which option outlined by Reinbold will be chosen to satisfy the NPS requirements.


Get Government & Politics updates in your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Porter County Reporter

Joyce has been a reporter for nearly 40 years, including 23 years with The Times. She's a native of Merrillville, but has lived in Portage for 39 years. She covers municipal and school government in Porter County.

Related to this story

CHESTERTON — Dunes Action co-founder Jim Sweeney read from a 2015 newspaper article outlining the schedule for the renovations of the pavilion…

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News


Entertainment & Dining

Latest News

Local Sports

NWI Prep Sport News

Weather Alerts