State Sen. Karen Tallian, D-Ogden Dunes, is seeking the Democratic Party nomination for Indiana attorney general.
In an exclusive interview with The Times, Tallian said she believes the state’s Republican-dominated government is crying out for partisan balance, and her experience both as a lawyer and lawmaker “could very well be the balance needed.”
“We have had a one-party trifecta for the last decade, and no one has been there in a position of authority to really be able to do anything about that,” Tallian said.
“We make our arguments in the Legislature, but they often go unheard. The attorney general's office has authority to do a lot of things.”
Specifically, the Valparaiso University Law School graduate said she would focus as attorney general on enhancing the office’s Medicaid fraud and senior citizen abuse investigations, go after charter schools that take taxpayer funds without educating students, and launch a payroll fraud unit to protect Hoosier workers who are misclassified as independent contractors or paid under the table.
Tallian also would remove Indiana from a pending federal lawsuit — championed by Republican Attorney General Curtis Hill Jr. — that seeks to declare unconstitutional the entire Affordable Care Act, which, if successful, once again would permit discrimination based on preexisting health conditions and eliminate significant federal funding for the Healthy Indiana Plan that covers more than 400,000 Hoosiers.
“It's just not right that our attorney general, who is supposed to be an advocate for citizens, is actively playing in a right-wing pursuit to get rid of health care,” Tallian said.
"Nationally, the Democratic attorneys general are fighting this, and I hope to be one of them. We need to keep health care for preexisting conditions, we need to keep it affordable, and we need to keep the Healthy Indiana Plan — which was a Republican program.”
Along that same line, Tallian said she would take an active role as attorney general in discouraging the General Assembly from enacting clearly unconstitutional legislation, as it repeatedly has over the past decade to limit access to abortion and other reproductive health care for women.
The Portage-based lawyer noted that Indiana has paid millions of dollars in attorney fees to the American Civil Liberties Union following their successful constitutional challenges to Indiana’s abortion laws; money that could have been put to better use directly helping Hoosiers.
"The attorney general can give the Legislature opinions about the language and what they're doing and is this proposal legit,” Tallian said. “In my years there, they have not done that, and I assume the reason is because the attorney general has always been the same party."
Tallian acknowledged that the Republican-controlled House and Senate could ignore her advice.
But they would do so at their own peril, since it would be clear from the get-go that the state’s own attorney believes what they’re passing is unconstitutional, she said.
“As an attorney, I've always been giving the other side of some argument. You learn early that there are two sides to every story,” Tallian said. "Running for attorney general to me is the next step in being an advocate for the other side."
Tallian also dismissed the possibility that, if she’s elected, the Legislature will make the attorney general a governor-appointed post, as it recently did with the state superintendent of public instruction, or eliminate the office altogether, since it only is created in statute, not by the Indiana Constitution.
"To get rid of the attorney general as an elected position would be a really risky move for any party,” Tallian said. "First of all, what goes around comes around, and we're not guaranteed that we'll have a Republican governor until the end of time."
Tallian though only has known Republican governors since first being elected to the Indiana Senate in 2005, following the resignation of state Sen. Rose Ann Antich-Carr, D-Merrillville.
Voters in Senate District 4, which now includes Ogden Dunes, Portage, Chesterton, South Haven, Burns Harbor, Beverly Shores, Michigan City and Westville, re-elected Tallian in 2006, 2010, 2014 and 2018.
She briefly ran for the Democratic gubernatorial nomination in 2016, but Tallian perhaps is best known for her efforts to legalize marijuana in Indiana — notwithstanding the opposition of Govs. Mitch Daniels, Mike Pence and Eric Holcomb.
Tallian said she would continue that work as attorney general by offering informed legal guidance on marijuana issues, instead of following Hill’s line that all marijuana is illegal and that’s that.
But health care and marijuana aren’t the only issues where she disagrees with the incumbent officeholder.
She thinks Hill has been ignoring Hoosiers to play in national politics, including his repeated White House visits to hobnob with President Donald Trump.
"Looking back at some of Curtis Hill's 2016 election material and websites, it seems clear to me now that he certainly sold himself as much more middle of the road than his positions have shown him to be,” Tallian said.
"He appears to be promoting an extreme right-wing agenda and using the office to do that."
At the same time, Tallian said she stands with the four women, including state Rep. Mara Candelaria Reardon, D-Munster, who have accused Hill of touching them on their backs or buttocks without consent during a 2018 legislative party, and Tallian believes Hill’s alleged behavior — which he continues to deny — has “tainted the integrity of the office.”
Tallian insisted, however, that she’s not running specifically to oust Hill, who Holcomb and GOP legislative leaders urged to resign following the groping allegations.
Hill also is the subject of a pending disciplinary complaint before the Indiana Supreme Court that could result in the temporary or permanent suspension of his law license.
"He may not even be the attorney general by the time this race happens in November 2020. But I am running on my own record,” Tallian said.
“If my opponent is Curtis Hill, fine. If it's somebody else, I'm still running on my record, and I'm still running on the fact that we need balance in the Statehouse.”
Tallian contends that next year is a unique opportunity to put before Hoosier voters the issues she believes the attorney general’s office should be addressing, without the distraction of a big U.S. Senate or state schools chief race on the ballot.
“I have a lot of things to say about the AG's office in particular, and I'm not going to make this as a side note to a governor's race. I plan on making this a focused fight for that office,” Tallian said. "I think I can win."
To win, Tallian first will need to claim the Democratic nomination at the party’s June 13, 2020, state convention. She so far is running unopposed.
The last Democrat to serve as Indiana attorney general was Gary Mayor Karen Freeman-Wilson, who was appointed in 2000 by Gov. Frank O’Bannon to complete the term of Jeff Modisett.
In 2016, Hill defeated now-Lake County Clerk Lorenzo Arredondo 62% to 38% in a race that got little attention that year amid open-seat contests for president, governor and U.S. senator.
Get Government & Politics updates in your inbox!
Stay up-to-date on the latest in local and national government and political topics with our newsletter.