Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Father buries son — killed over an Xbox — on Father's Day: 'They took well over half my soul'

Father buries son — killed over an Xbox — on Father's Day: 'They took well over half my soul'


MERRILLVILLE — Johnny Peluyera cried tears of joy when he first saw the bright blue Trans Am.

As promised, his father John Peluyera bought him the sports car he always dreamed of. He had just earned his driver's license, which was en route in the mail.

Once the 16-year-old attained his diploma from Merrillville High School in two years, John Peluyera planned to sign over the title of the Pontiac Firebird to his son as a graduation gift.

Instead, he ended up burying his son on Father's Day.

"When they took my son, they took well over half my soul," he said. "He needs to be brought to justice. His family will pay when he's brought to justice."

Peluyera, a Merrillville High School student who was two-and-a-half months from his 17th birthday, was fatally shot in the back Wednesday in an attempted robbery of an Xbox he had arranged online to sell so he could buy a new phone. His father drove his son to the 5000 block of Maryland Street in Gary. There, a prospective buyer brandished a handgun and shot him in the back as he ran back to the car's passenger seat, with the video game console still in his hands.

"I pray to God justice will be served," his father said. "I'm going to leave it to the Lord and the law."

His tearful father spent the day at Calumet Park Funeral Chapel Sunday receiving hugs and condolences from a procession of heartbroken friends and family members.

Peluyera was buried with his Merrillville High School ID, an Xbox controller and his beloved Air Jordans. His Trans Am — waxed to a high sheen — was parked outside the funeral home with "RIP Johnny" written on the windows in white paint. Family and friends say the "happy-go-lucky" teen was into video games, collecting shoes and pranks.

He was a middle child between his older sister Vanessa Peluyera and their 8-year-old brother, Cayden Peluyera, who looked up to him as a role model. He often joked with and chased his mother, Kelly Arroyo, around the house.

"He had a wonderful personality," his father said. "He was a stay-at-home kid, did not run the streets. He loved to make his mom laugh. It was his goal every day to make his mom smile. He had a special bond with his mom."

Peluyera, who had just completed his sophomore year of high school and whose first job was at a Halloween store last fall, dreamed of one day becoming a video game programmer, building cars and just enjoying life, his father said.

"He enjoyed what life had to offer," he said. "When he learned how to ride his first dirt bike, he had the biggest smile on his face. He was really big into quads and dirt bikes."

He liked working on cars with his dad and was looking forward to driving the Trans Am.

"That was his goal to be the best he could be to make me happy and do the best he could do," he said. "He always did the right thing, stayed out of trouble, and stayed off the streets. He was a family guy, a friends guy."

Tracie Butz, a friend of Peluyera's mother and the mother of one of Peluyera's closest friends, said she's known the boy for much of his life.

"He was a great kid, a real jokester," she said. "He was funny and goofy and always made people laugh."

Her son Alex Butz, Aryan Terry, Fabian Rivera and Jaysen Massie were part of a close-knit group of friends who grew up with him. They fondly remembered going swimming with him in a neighbor's pool, him crashing into a wall while trying not to fall while roller skating at the Lynwood Sports Center in Lynwood and his love of pizza and other junk food.

"He was always laughing, always joking," Terry said. "He always tried to make sure everyone ate. He'd always ask, 'Are you hungry?'"

They said he loved walking to the gas station and was "always hungry." He loved cars, was a sneakerhead and played many video games like Call of Duty, Fortnite, Rocket League and Apex Legends, giving his used games to his little brother.

"He was pretty good, really good at Fortnite," Massie said. "I ain't even going to lie, he was the best at Rocket League. He loved Rocket League."

His friends said that they loved Peluyera and that he would never be forgotten.

"He was my brother," Alex Butz said at the funeral home Sunday. "He was one of the only people I could trust in my life. I don't trust nobody. If I have to go through another one of these, I don't think I can."

They're still stunned by the senselessness of his death.

"I can't believe it was over an Xbox," Butz said. "And they didn't even get it."

Anyone with information is asked to call Detective Mike Equihua of the Lake/Gary Metro Homicide Unit at 219-755-3852. To remain anonymous, call 866-CRIME-GP.

Recent arrests booked into Lake County Jail


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Business Reporter

Joseph S. Pete is a Lisagor Award-winning business reporter who covers steel, industry, unions, the ports, retail, banking and more. The Indiana University grad has been with The Times since 2013 and blogs about craft beer, culture and the military.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News


Entertainment & Dining

Latest News

Local Sports

NWI Prep Sport News

Weather Alerts