Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.

Indiana doctor: AG shouldn't get abortion patient records

Lawyers for an Indianapolis doctor who provided an abortion to a 10-year-old rape victim from Ohio told a judge Friday that Indiana’s attorney general should not be allowed to access patient medical records for an investigation into undisclosed complaints

  • Updated
  • 0

INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Lawyers for an Indianapolis doctor who provided an abortion to a 10-year-old rape victim from Ohio told a judge Friday that Indiana’s attorney general should not be allowed to access patient medical records for an investigation into undisclosed complaints.

Dr. Caitlin Bernard; her medical partner, Dr. Amy Caldwell; and their patients sued Republican Attorney General Todd Rokita on Nov. 3 to try to stop him from accessing the records. The doctors claim Rokita's conduct “violates numerous Indiana statutes,” including a state requirement that his office first determine consumer complaints have “merit” before he can investigate physicians and other licensed professionals.

The state argued it is allowed to access the records to investigate three consumer complaints that accuse Bernard of improper care.

“The consumer complaints were 100% filed by people who had never met Dr. Bernard, had never gotten medical care from Dr. Bernard, were not involved in the care of this patient in any way shape or form,” attorney Kathleen DeLaney refuted in a press conference after the hearing. “They’re complaining about something that they saw on television or heard about on social media.”

Bernard first received national attention after she told The Indianapolis Star about a 10-year-old girl who traveled to Indiana from Ohio for an abortion in June, shortly after Ohio’s “fetal heartbeat” law took effect following the U.S. Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade. Such laws ban abortions from the time cardiac activity can be detected in an embryo, which is typically around the sixth week of pregnancy.

Rokita told Fox News in July that he would look into whether Bernard violated child abuse notification or abortion reporting laws. He offered no specific allegations of wrongdoing, and court records from Thursday indicate he is no longer investigating Bernard “for failing to comply” with the abortion reporting law.

Records obtained by The Associated Press and other news outlets show Bernard submitted her report about the girl’s abortion July 2, which is within Indiana’s required three-day reporting period for an abortion performed on a girl younger than 16.

A 27-year-old man was charged that month in Columbus, Ohio, with raping the girl, confirming the existence of the case, which initially was met with skepticism by some media outlets and Republican politicians. President Joe Biden expressed empathy for the child while signing of an executive order protecting some abortion access.

Kelly Stevenson, a spokesperson for the attorney general’s office, said in an email that “our team always follows the law and pursues the truth — as that is the role of the Attorney General.”

“We put the highest value on patient privacy and ethical standards in medicine. We will continue to push forward in this legal battle to ensure every patient’s privacy is protected in Indiana,” she added.

But DeLaney said that because of the 27-year-old man's arrest, “the notion that Dr. Barnard didn’t cooperate with law enforcement is simply not true.”

State lawyer Caryn Nieman-Szyper on Friday also questioned whether anything Bernard said to The Indianapolis Star violated federal medical privacy laws. Nieman-Szyper honed in specifically on rules under the federal privacy law known as HIPAA, for Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, that prohibit a physician from divulging certain dates associated with their patients.

“Though Dr. Bernard purports to bring suit as the champion of her patient’s privacy rights, she is the one who exposed her patient’s private medical journey to the public and thus the one who has jeopardized her patient’s privacy,” the state wrote in court filings.

At the court hearing, the doctors' lawyers called three physicians — two bioethicists and an obstetrician-gynecologist — who described before Marion County judge Heather Welch that honoring the doctor-patient relationship is a cornerstone of medical care.

Dr. Kyle Brothers, a pediatrician from Louisville, described the link as “an agreement, a promise" and that if the government were to seize a patient's medical records, the patient's trust in their doctor could be broken and dissuade them from seeking care.

“This kind of disclosure, especially for a minor, is heartbreaking, or something like that," he said. "Something really horrible.”

Welch plans to rule over the weekend whether Bernard, who was out of the country Friday, will testify.

“Every patient needs to know that their medical records will not be handed over to any politician who decides to open an unfounded investigation based on their own political agenda,” Bernard said in a statement.

Arleigh Rodgers is a corps member for the Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues. Follow Arleigh Rodgers on Twitter at

This story has been corrected to show the doctor's lawyer is called Kathleen DeLaney, not Kathleen Delaney.

Copyright 2022 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.


* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

A former northern Indiana doctor has been sentenced to one year in jail after admitting that he sexually battered two patients during examinations. Fifty-three-year-old Darryl Henry received a 2½-year sentence for each count of sexual battery he pleaded guilty to, but his jail time was capped at one year under the plea agreement he entered in August. The Elkhart Truth reports that an Elkhart County judge told Henry that he had violated his Hippocratic Oath with his behavior toward his female patients. Henry was arrested in August 2019 on a warrant issued after police investigated claims made by two female patients.

An Indiana judge says she will decide soon whether to unseal court records that led to a man’s arrest last month in the 2017 killings of two teenage girls. During a hearing Tuesday, Special Judge Fran Gull acknowledged that there's great public interest in the case against 50-year-old Richard M. Allen and said she'll decide whether to unseal the records “in due haste.” Allen was arrested last month and charged with two counts of murder in the February 2017 killings of 14-year-old Liberty “Libby” German and 13-year-old Abigail “Abby” Williams. The girls' bodies were found a day after they were dropped off at a hiking trail outside of their hometown of Delphi, where Allen lives.

An Indiana judge could rule Tuesday if sealed court documents with evidence that led to a man’s arrest in the 2017 slayings of two teenage girls will be publicly released. Richard Matthew Allen, a 50-year-old of Delphi, Indiana, was charged last month with two counts of murder in the killings of Liberty German, 14, and Abigail Williams, 13, but the court documents were sealed at the request of the local prosecutor. State police have revealed incremental details about the case since investigations first began, but public calls for more details have accelerated since Allen's Oct. 28 arrest on two murder counts in the killings.

Police say the pilot of a small plane escaped injury when the aircraft made an emergency landing using a large parachute to descend before landing in a suburban Indianapolis pond. The plane landed Friday morning along the edge of a pond near the Indianapolis Regional Airport in Hancock County near the unincorporated community of Mount Comfort. State police Sgt. John Perrine tells WRTV-TV the pilot was located uninjured after deploying a parachute to guide the aircraft down to a pond. It wasn't immediately clear what led to the emergency landing. But WRTV-TV posted a witness' video showing the aircraft floating down on a parachute beneath an apparent smoke plume.

The University of Nebraska-Lincoln will consider changing its policy on the way student fees are distributed after being sued by a Christian student group that alleged it had been discriminated against. The changes the Board of Regents will consider at its meeting next month are part of a settlement between the university and the Ratio Christi student group. The group said in its lawsuit that it was denied $1,500 to bring a Christian philosopher to campus as a guest speaker. The new set of rules the Regents will consider will be viewpoint neutral. Instead, speakers will judged based on their academic reputation and whether the speech will advance the university's educational mission.

Crews continued working Tuesday to douse a fire that began over the weekend in southern Indiana’s Brown County State Park and has scorched more than 100 acres. The brush fire was reported Sunday evening on the park's east side. Marty Benson, a spokesman for the Indiana Department of Natural Resource, tells The Herald-Times that by sundown Monday, fire crews had created a fire line and halted the fire’s spread. Benson says a five-man DNR crew returned Tuesday to continue working the fire. Brown County State Park is one of Indiana’s most popular state parks and at 16,000 acres it's the state's largest state park.

An Indianapolis doctor who provided abortion drugs to a 10-year-old rape victim from Ohio has defended her actions before a judge in the case that drew national attention in the weeks after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in June. Dr. Caitlin Bernard testified Monday during the second day of a court hearing on attempt to block Indiana’s Republican attorney general from seeking patient medical records for an investigation of whether she properly reported child abuse and possibly violated patient privacy laws by telling a newspaper reporter about the girl’s case. The Marion County judge said she expected to issue a decision next week on whether to issue a preliminary injunction against the attorney general’s office.

A man who pleaded guilty to torching several barns last year in a northern Indiana county has been sentenced to 50 years in prison followed by decades on probation. An Elkhart County judge sentenced 42-year-old Joseph Hershberger to 96 years Monday, but suspended nearly half of that sentence and ordered Hershberger to serve 46 years on probation following his release. He must also pay $80,000 in fines. Hershberger pleaded guilty in October to eight counts of arson while admitting that he set fire to eight barns in Elkhart County. Hershberger’s girlfriend, Sherry Thomas, was also charged last year in Elkhart County with eight counts of arson in the barn fires.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News


Entertainment & Dining

Latest News

Local Sports

NWI Prep Sport News

Weather Alerts