Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Crown Point resident, Andrean transfer Benson finds new home at Chesterton
Prep baseball

Crown Point resident, Andrean transfer Benson finds new home at Chesterton


For most of his young baseball career, Tommy Benson was always the little guy.

"I was so small, I really focused on my defense — that's what got me on the field — the fundamentals, getting my swing," he said. "My dad said it was like a curse and a blessing."

Last spring, the Chesterton senior stood 5-foot-10 and weighed 168 pounds. After starting a high-volume, high-protein diet in October, he's now playing a 6-0, 197 pounds.

"Something had to change," Benson said. "I hit my first home run last summer. talked to (sports trainer) Ken Croner and he said if you want to gain weight, you have to eat, eat, eat. I took it to heart. People think, 'Oh, it's not hard, eating all the time,' but it's not as easy as it sounds. It's as hard as losing weight. It's funny, once I started eating six meals a day, I'm so full, I hardly ever eat candy anymore. I can't remember the last time I had a cookie."

A bulkier Benson is now bashing the ball with more authority.

"I'm more confident," he said. "It's the same swing, just with different results. All that doesn't matter much unless you can hit the ball. I'm just hitting it so much farther."

Benson's exit velocity, which he measures on Hit Trax at the Sports Performance Institute, has jumped from 92 to 102 miles per hour, while his arm strength has jumped from 79 to 93. Trojans coach Jack Campbell is far from a big analytics guy. He measures things by results and he likes what he sees.

"He's got a quick bat," Campbell said. "He's got great mechanics. I kept telling him, I haven't seen you healthy."

A starting shortstop at Andrean as a sophomore, Benson transferred to Chesterton last year. Slowed by bicep tendinitis, he was a part-time player initially, eventually breaking into the lineup at second base after Grant Brunt got beaned against Michigan City.

"A lot of times, guys are like, 'Oh, he's taking my place,'" Campbell said. "He fit in really well. He's been nothing but a great kid, on and off the field."

Having played a few summers earlier on the Duneland Flyers, Benson already knew Austin Peterson, Stephen Gilbertsen, Chris Torres and Brunt, which helped in his school transition.

"I didn't know a lot of people, but the baseball guys were absolutely great," he said. "They couldn't have been any better, accepting me. Guys I had no idea who they were made me feel like I've known them seven years. We're best buds now."

So exactly how does someone who lives in Crown Point and attended Andrean end up at Chesterton? Benson attended St. Mary's School through eighth grade and his dad, Phil is an Andrean graduate, so it was no surprise he ended up at the Catholic school. With Phil Benson's work as a federal prosecutor taking him to Porter County, Tommy said the family planned to move to Chesterton, where they had lived years ago. They were unable to sell their house in C.P., where they still live, so he makes the daily 45-minute drive to school.

Part of the work-study program, Benson only has class from 8 to 11 a.m. and hangs out at a friend's house in town until baseball in the afternoon.

"We really loved the area," Benson said.

The geography has been the subject of debate and Benson's change is schools is the supposed reason Andrean and Chesterton stopped playing. That said, Benson holds no animosity toward his former teammates, whom he faced last season, nor vice versa.

"I've got three groups of friends," he said. "I hang out with those guys on weekends. They're my buddies. (Andrean's) Tyler Nelson is my neighbor. There are five Andrean guys on my travel team (Midwest Irish). It has nothing to do with Dave Pishkur. Both coaches are great. All the players are great. No one has hard feelings. There's no one I don't like, no one I don't hang out with."

A shortstop all of his life, Benson was initially slated to attend Parkland, a two-year college in Champaign, Illinois, but will now head to IMG Academy in Florida to develop his game, possibly doing some pitching and working on being a switch hitter. In a year's time, he hopes to latch on with a four-year school.

"My parents decided it was the best place for me," Benson said. "I'd be happy anywhere playing baseball. My whole life has centered around baseball. I want to play as long as I can."

The Times Baseball Top 10


Get in the game with our Prep Sports Newsletter

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Sports reporter

Jim was keeping standings on his chalkboard from the time he could print and keeping kickball stats in grade school at St. Bridget's. He covers all manner of prep sports for The Times and is a long-suffering Chicago Cubs fan.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News


Entertainment & Dining

Latest News

Local Sports

NWI Prep Sport News

Weather Alerts