Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Gary police I.D. another body

Gary police I.D. another body

GARY - Two women walked out of a Lake Station courtroom July 18.

Sufficiently jolted by the criminal episode, one checked into a rehabilitation

center. Her friend did not.

It was the last time Wanda Kleine saw or heard from Tonya Dunlap.

"Oh, my goodness. No!" Kleine said Tuesday after hearing that Dunlap was

identified as one of suspected serial killer Eugene V. Britt's victims.

Gary police found Dunlap's decomposed corpse Nov. 8 in the woods near the

6800 block of Melton Road after Britt, 38, allegedly told them where to look.

Dunlap, 24, was finally identified through dental records obtained from her


Although her official address was in Knox, Dunlap spent most of her time in

and around Gary. There, acquaintances and police records indicate, she lived a

transient lifestyle, going from address to address with others familiar with

surviving on the streets and smoking crack cocaine.

Kleine said Dunlap was known around Gary as "Cutie Pie," her citizens band

radio name. Dunlap also was well acquainted with the strip of U.S. 20 near

where her body was eventually found, Kleine said.

Kleine and Dunlap were arrested together June 14 on criminal trespass

charges at the Speedway truck stop on Ripley Street in Lake Station. They spent

two nights in jail, two nights that Kleine said changed her life.

"It scared me. That was it. I started a new life," Kleine said, pausing.

"This could have been me. It makes me more thankful that I walked away from it."

Kleine also spent time on the streets with Cleaster "Precious" McNeil,

another woman believed to be raped and strangled by Britt.

"Tonya, she jumped into things too quick," Kleine said. "But Cleaster, she

was kind of the hard type, bossy. She knew it all."

Like most of Britt's alleged victims, the women were vulnerable because of

their addiction to crack cocaine and their reliance on prostitution to obtain

money that was funneled into their drug habit.

Kleine said Dunlap had a 2-year-old son.

Candelaria Dunlap, Dunlap's mother, reported her daughter missing at the

Hammond Police Department on Nov. 9, the day after police found Dunlap's

skeletal remains.

In the missing person report, Candelaria Dunlap said the last time her

daughter was seen was at 8 a.m. July 18 at Lake Station city court. She told

police her daughter "frequents Gary and truck stops," said Hammond police Sgt.

Richard Hoyda.

Britt's alleged killing spree began in early summer and ended with McNeil's

murder Sept. 12. He was arrested in November after DNA tests linked him to the

slaying in August of 8-year-old Sarah Lynn Paulsen of Portage.

Members of the Indiana Army National Guard on Saturday located the remains

of another suspected Britt victim. Those remains, still unidentified, were

found in the woods in the 1000 block of Martin Luther King Drive.

Britt has allegedly given police a vague idea of where they may find the

remains of his only male victim. That corpse continues to elude searchers.


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News


Entertainment & Dining

Latest News

Local Sports

NWI Prep Sport News

Weather Alerts